Wednesday, 18 July 2007

Avatars, alias and being what or who you aren't

I have been considering for some time now the long term implications behind the idea that we explain to children that they should not, online, in any way reveal who they are or where they are from. It occurs to me that this is an extension of role play into a real/virtual world situation. As I think of it, the idea seems okay for early years explorations but I am getting increasingly insecure about it as children get older. Should we be encouraging them to pretend to be someone they are not and not accept (by default) the implications of their real and virtual actions? It is a good argument to say that they are modeling in a true sense in situations that they can manipulate to see outcomes and can, for the most part, retract and come out unscathed. But is it socially viable, in the long term, as the blend between the physical world and the virtual one becomes blurred? ( Have you visited Second Life recently?)It seems to me that as we build the various levels of sub-worlds which people (children) inhabit then we are in danger of them becoming more of a reality than reality. Although I am not a 'film' person, can't sit long enough to get the whole thing, the film 'Matrix' had a profound effect on me when I first saw it. And the concept of 'worlds within worlds' has always fascinated. 'But doesn't everyone do this?' I hear you all shout ... so why am I bothered?

Labels:

5 Comments:

At 18 July 2007 18:06 , Anonymous Linda said...

Why are we bothered ... because real experiences (probably as an immature teenager)tell us that promising something we're not get's us into trouble. I'm uncomfortable with adults that use (hide behind?) avatar's because it suggests concealment and I wonder what there is to hide

 
At 20 July 2007 15:04 , Blogger James Watson said...

Television is virtual reality, video games are virtual reality. They are both designed to distract people from talking to each other and engaging with the real world, thus dumbing us down so we're not informed about the real world.

 
At 20 July 2007 15:09 , Blogger Doug said...

Hence my reference to the 'Matrix'

 
At 26 July 2007 16:17 , Blogger Mr Harrington said...

Doug I have ventured into Second Life recently - partly to see what all of the fuss is about. When there I immediately feel awkward inhabiting an avatar and assuming a name/persona which is not mine!!! it is this part of the whole experience that I find 'bothers me!' I can see uses for bringing disparate people together in one space - also using SL's new voice facility, but I would be concerned about using it in a school setting.

 
At 07 August 2007 15:31 , Blogger Ewan McIntosh said...

For many there really is an appeal and desire to be someone different in their second life:
http://www.loiclemeur.com/english/2007/06/the_appeal_of_v.html

It's not always a bad thing to allow people to imagine and dream beyond their four walls of real life.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home