Saturday, 27 January 2007

Podium or Audacity ?

I often get told by people that they are podcasting and, when I question them, I discover that they are recording sound and uploading the MP3 file to a web space somewhere or putting the recording in a blog etc ... this is beginning to annoy me a lot.

So ... Podium .V. Audacity

The difference is actually quite simple, they do different things.

Podium enables you to plan, record, edit, publish and promote podcasts. Audacity doesn’t.

It's important that we are clear that podcasts have multiple episodes and once they are subscribed to they are automatically delivered. If you create single, stand alone sound file, you are not podcasting, you are recording a sound file…full stop … simple as that.

Audacity allows you to record and edit sound files. It's an excellent piece of software but it doesn't create podcasts. Audacity is the sound recorder and is one way of creating the first part of the podcasting process. To create podcasts you need other pieces of software, pieces of software which, potentially, are going to put people off creating their own podcasts because they were developed for the technically capable.

Podium creates a podcast and the multiple episodes which exist within it, together with an image per episode. It can also create chapters in each episode, each of which can be recorded and edited individually. It also contains a scripting tool which enables children to script their podcast, hence embedding literacy and planning activities into the creation of the podcast. It then publishes the podcast to the internet and lets you promote your podcast to your potential audience. Audacity doesn't do any of this because it wasn't created for this purpose.

Podium also allows you to record edit and produce your podcast, importing sound effects and music, as well as recording speech. This is the area of functionality which Audacity also does, in quite a sophisticated way. Podium was created for use by teachers and pupils, Audacity, and the related pieces of software, were created for the adult world and are not anywhere near as intuitive as Podium.

The acid test would be to sit a group of teachers and pupils in front of Podium and Audacity, ask them to create a podcast and .Spend the five minutes it takes to take a look at Podium and you'll see why it is the way to put podcasting in the hands of those that matter most, teachers and pupils.

Labels: ,

5 Comments:

At 04 February 2007 21:44 , Blogger Dearg Doom said...

Yes - as ever Doug a simple and clear definition and sensible explanation of the main differences between Audacity and Podium.

 
At 19 February 2007 05:07 , Blogger Shambles Guru said...

Podium or Audacity ? .... or
WavePad (also free download but not open source)

WavePad is a great alternative to Audacity for editing audio ... there is a free version and it supports more file types than Audactity.

More info at "Podcasting Tools"
http://www.shambles.net/pages/learning/infolit/podsoft/

 
At 19 February 2007 05:11 , Blogger Shambles Guru said...

UMmmm URL did not come out well in previous comment so ..

Go to
www.shambles.net/podcasting
and click on "Podcasting Tools"

 
At 19 February 2007 05:15 , Blogger Shambles Guru said...

Now how about "Podium" vs "GarageBand" comparison .... that would be interesting.

Doug... is sounds like time for a comparison chart ... which you are now going to tell me is already out there somewhere

 
At 01 March 2007 12:21 , Blogger City Learning Centre said...

Doug, I totally agree, the only difference is that Podium is a paid for product. Granted it IS BRILLIANT.

I teach Teachers to make their mp3 recordings in Audacity, then for the simplest solution upload them to a blog, this uses the blog feed to announce the updates.

Whilst I'm aware that this isn't strictly podcasting, the feed can be altered to be compliant with that strange animal-Itunes.

It also allows people to get their feet wet before spending a penny.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home